Carla Harvey Explains That She Left The Butcher Babies to Focus on Her “Death-Care” Career
It came as a big shock to a lot of people as, over the past year, Carla Harvey seemed to slowly step away from femme-forward metal act Butcher Babies, leading to the announcement of her official departure from the band in July. It was difficult to read between the lines and try to tell if she left over some drama in the band, but it now seems to be confirmed that band drama had nothing to do with it. It seems that Harvey left primarily to focus on her other passion: being a death-care specialist.
Harvey, who has degrees in mortuary management and is certified as a grief coach and bereavement specialist, recently explained in an interview on the podcast The Dr. Ward Bond Show (that was transcribed by Blabbermouth) why she left the band:
“It’s quite interesting because [prior to BUTCHER BABIES] I had come to a point living in L.A., you get opportunities and they’re snatched away from you. You make money, then you lose your money. And I was so tired of the entertainment business. And I was, like, ‘I don’t wanna do this anymore. I don’t wanna play music anymore. I don’t wanna act anymore. It’s too much. Nothing is ever gonna happen with it.’ So that’s when I went to mortuary school and I was committed to only working in funeral service from then on out. Well, after a couple years of working, I got my dream job at a very big mortuary in L.A. And at the same time, I got an opportunity to start my band and go on tour for the first time in my life. So I had to make a choice in that moment. I’ve committed myself to this death-care career. Do I drop it all, everything that I’ve worked so hard for in school, and go on tour with this band and just see what happens one final time, or do I just stick on my path? And I chose music in that moment, and that was 2009 that I really committed back to music, and 2012 we went on our — we were touring non-stop, so there was no way I could work in funeral service anymore. Well, it ended up being the best thing that ever happened to me because our career just exploded, and so I got the best of both worlds. I had gotten my education. I had gotten a taste of working in death care, and then I could still live out my dream, and I am so grateful for that. The last 15 years of my life have been spent on stage, entertaining people in a capacity that I never dreamed I would have, especially after so much disappointment in my early years in L.A. So I got to do that. I got to be a rock star. I got to do all the things. And then 15 years later, my mind kind of changed again. [Laughs]”
She then continued:
“My dad said something to me once years ago, when we had started the band, and he meant it in jest. He said, ‘I saw you singing on the Internet. Don’t quit your day job.’ And at the time I was, like, ‘That’s the nastiest thing you could say.’ But I’m glad I never quit my day job. In fact, all the while, the last 15 years, while I’ve been on tour, I’ve been getting more education and getting more certification so that I could continue on because I always had that need to still be in death care in some aspect. I founded my grief coaching company so that I could still be of service to people who need me in that capacity. It was very important to me. And then last year, I was on this major summer tour. We were playing sheds, the outdoor amphitheaters and it was wonderful and every day you’re up on stage singing your heart out, but, man, I saw this post about [innovative solidified remains company] Parting Stone looking for a partner success manager. And I thought, ‘Man, I wanna apply for this. I wanna see what happens if I can take this job.’”
She then added:
“There’s just so many moments in life where you really have to assess what’s best for you. Life changes. And also another thing about the entertainment industry and the music industry, it’s not the same as it was for musicians 20 years ago, 10 years ago. My future husband’s [ANTHRAX and PANTERA drummer Charlie Benante] in a legacy band. They never have to worry about having a real job — ever. But bands my size? You’re not breaking the bank. You’re not really earning a livable wage unless you’re on the road 12 months out of the year. You can’t support yourself. So I’ve always had other jobs, whether I’m painting pictures for people or doing my grief coaching on the side. That’s a day job that I’ve been able to maintain throughout my career with music. It was a necessity as well as a passion, because otherwise I’d be couch surfing somewhere. [Laughs] I have nothing. So it’s really hard to live passionately and just follow your dreams without something to fall back on or something to assist you. And I tell this to a lot of people, and some people are, like, ‘No, man. I don’t want a backup plan. This is the only thing I’m ever gonna do.’”
While that’s all well and good, it does raise the question of why she started her new project The Violent Hour, which she announced on social media next month. Judging by what she said about why she exited The Butcher Babies, it’s probably safe to assume that The Violent Hour will be a little more laid-back and not have a very rigorous touring schedule. But hey, people have to do what makes them happy.
